Skip to content
EB5Status
Official Data
Federal courts and USCIS AAO

Key Court Cases and Precedent Decisions

EB-5 law has been shaped by landmark decisions from federal courts and the USCIS Administrative Appeals Office (AAO). These decisions establish the standards that adjudicators apply when reviewing petitions, from the at-risk requirement to source of funds documentation to processing timelines. Understanding precedent is essential for attorneys advising EB-5 clients.

Sources: Federal court decisions, USCIS AAO precedent decisions · Last reviewed: April 2026

Key Takeaways

  • •Matter of Izummi (1998) remains the foundational precedent on the at-risk requirement, holding that capital must face genuine risk of both gain and loss.
  • •Matter of Ho (1998) established the business plan standard requiring demonstrable job creation projections based on verifiable economic data.
  • •Matter of Soffici (1998) set the source of funds chain-of-custody documentation requirement that remains central to petition adjudication.
  • •Recent federal court decisions have addressed processing delays, fee rules, and the consequences of program lapses, expanding the legal landscape beyond the traditional AAO precedent framework.

Landmark Decisions

Matter of Izummi

At-Risk Requirement

22 I&N Dec. 169 (AAO 1998)

Holding:

Capital must be placed at risk with no guaranteed return. Arrangements that protect the investor from loss are inconsistent with the statutory "at risk" requirement. The possibility of gain and loss must be genuine, not theoretical.

Practical Impact:

Established the foundational standard for evaluating whether EB-5 investments meet the at-risk requirement. Cited in virtually every USCIS adjudication involving investment structure questions.

Matter of Ho

Business Plan / Job Creation

22 I&N Dec. 206 (AAO 1998)

Holding:

Established the comprehensive business plan standard for EB-5 petitions. A business plan must demonstrate a reasonable likelihood of creating the required number of jobs within a reasonable period, based on verifiable economic projections rather than speculative assumptions.

Practical Impact:

Remains the controlling standard for evaluating business plans. The "Matter of Ho requirements" are routinely referenced in RFEs and denial notices.

Matter of Soffici

Source of Funds

22 I&N Dec. 158 (AAO 1998)

Holding:

Defined the requirements for demonstrating lawful source of funds. The investor must trace the path of funds from the original source to the new commercial enterprise, showing that the capital was obtained through lawful means. Unresolved gaps in the chain of documentation can be grounds for denial.

Practical Impact:

Established the source of funds documentation standard that remains central to EB-5 adjudication. The "chain of custody" requirement for tracing funds from origin to investment is directly derived from this decision.

Zhang v. USCIS

Source of Funds / Capital Definition

978 F.3d 1314 (D.C. Cir. 2020)

Holding:

The D.C. Circuit held that the proceeds of a third-party loan qualify as "cash" capital under 8 CFR 204.6(e), and that the USCIS Loan Proceeds Policy reclassifying such proceeds as collateralized "indebtedness" was inconsistent with the plain text of that regulation. The court decided the case on that regulatory-interpretation ground and did not rest its holding on any notice and comment or Administrative Procedure Act defect.

Practical Impact:

Invalidated the USCIS Loan Proceeds Policy and confirmed that investors may fund an EB-5 investment with the proceeds of an unsecured third-party loan. USCIS approved the underlying petition in 2021 and stopped classifying unsecured loan proceeds as indebtedness.

Behring Regional Center v. Wolf

EB-5 Modernization Rule

No. 20-cv-09263 (N.D. Cal. 2021)

Holding:

The court vacated the entire 2019 EB-5 Modernization Rule, finding that Acting DHS Secretary Kevin McAleenan was not lawfully serving under the Federal Vacancies Reform Act when he promulgated the rule, and that Secretary Mayorkas's later ratification could not cure that defect. The vacatur reverted the investment minimums to the pre-2019 amounts of $500,000 (TEA) and $1,000,000 (standard) until they were superseded by the RIA in 2022.

Practical Impact:

Disrupted the Modernization Rule framework and contributed to the uncertain regulatory environment that preceded the RIA. Demonstrated the vulnerability of executive branch EB-5 reforms to appointment-authority challenges under the Federal Vacancies Reform Act.

Behring Regional Center v. Mayorkas

Program Lapse / Pending Petitions

No. 3:22-cv-01049-AGT (N.D. Cal. 2022)

Holding:

After USCIS took the position that the regional center program had sunset on June 30, 2021 and stopped accepting new regional center petitions, Behring Regional Center sued under the Administrative Procedure Act to challenge that refusal. The case was voluntarily dismissed as moot once the EB-5 Reform and Integrity Act of 2022 reauthorized the program, so there was no merits ruling.

Practical Impact:

Illustrated the disruption a program lapse causes for regional center petitioners and the litigation it prompted. This is a separate case from the Behring v. Wolf entry above, which vacated the 2019 Modernization Rule. Here the dispute over how a lapse and later reauthorization affect pending cases fed into the grandfathering and transition provisions Congress wrote into the 2022 RIA.

Matter of Walsh and Pollard

E-2 Treaty Investor / Substantial Investment

20 I&N Dec. 60 (BIA 1988)

Holding:

An E-2 treaty-investor exclusion case involving two British nationals employed by a UK design firm working under contract with General Motors. The Board of Immigration Appeals held that no particular dollar amount is required for an investment to be considered substantial under the E-2 treaty-investor category; the investment must instead be enough to establish a viable, non-marginal enterprise.

Practical Impact:

This is an E-2 nonimmigrant treaty-investor decision, not an EB-5 precedent. It does not govern the definition of qualifying capital under the EB-5 immigrant investor program, which is set by statute and by 8 CFR 204.6.

EB-5 Fee Rule Litigation

USCIS Filing Fees

Multiple district courts (2024-2025)

Holding:

Federal courts in multiple jurisdictions addressed challenges to the April 2024 USCIS fee schedule, which significantly increased EB-5 filing fees. A November 2025 court ruling effectively reverted EB-5 fees to pre-April 2024 levels, reducing the I-526E filing fee from the proposed increase back to $3,675.

Practical Impact:

Directly affected the cost structure for EB-5 applicants. Demonstrated that USCIS fee-setting authority is subject to judicial review and that fee increases must satisfy reasonableness standards.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an AAO decision in the EB-5 context?

The Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) is the USCIS body that reviews appeals of denied EB-5 petitions. When an I-526E or I-829 petition is denied, the investor can appeal to the AAO. AAO decisions, particularly those designated as "adopted" or "precedent" decisions, establish interpretive standards that USCIS adjudicators follow in subsequent cases. While AAO decisions are not binding in the same way as federal court decisions, they represent the agency's authoritative interpretation of immigration law and are widely cited by practitioners.

Can EB-5 investors challenge USCIS decisions in federal court?

Yes. After exhausting administrative remedies (typically an AAO appeal), EB-5 investors can file suit in federal district court challenging USCIS decisions. Federal courts review USCIS actions under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), applying either the "arbitrary and capricious" standard or "abuse of discretion" standard depending on the type of decision. Several landmark EB-5 cases have been decided at the district and circuit court levels, including challenges to processing delays, fee rules, and regulatory interpretations.

How do court decisions affect pending EB-5 petitions?

Court decisions can have immediate or prospective effects depending on the scope of the ruling. Some decisions apply retroactively to pending cases (for example, when a court vacates a regulation, all cases governed by that regulation are affected). Other decisions apply only to the specific plaintiff or to cases filed after the decision date. USCIS typically issues policy guidance or updates to the Policy Manual following significant court decisions, which informs how adjudicators should handle affected petitions.

What is the most cited EB-5 precedent decision?

Matter of Izummi (22 I&N Dec. 169, AAO 1998) is among the most frequently cited EB-5 decisions. It established key standards for the "at risk" requirement, holding that capital must be subject to the possibility of both gain and loss, and that arrangements guaranteeing the return of capital are inconsistent with the program's requirements. The Izummi decision has shaped how USCIS evaluates investment structures and remains the foundational precedent on the at-risk requirement nearly three decades later.

Where can I find AAO decisions on EB-5 cases?

USCIS publishes designated precedent decisions and selected non-precedent decisions on its website. The AAO maintains a searchable database of decisions organized by topic and form type. For EB-5 cases, the most relevant decisions involve Form I-526 (and I-526E), Form I-829, and regional center designation applications. The AILA (American Immigration Lawyers Association) InfoNet also maintains a database of AAO decisions searchable by keyword. EB5Status tracks significant AAO decisions that establish new interpretive standards or clarify existing requirements.

Related Pages

Reform and Integrity Act: Section by Section | Analysis of the current governing legislation.

Legislative History | The full legislative timeline from 1990 to present.

EB-5 Glossary | Definitions of legal and technical terms referenced in these decisions.

Corrections | Our correction policy and data integrity standards.

Priority date movements, processing time changes, and policy updates.

Last updated: April 2026

EB5Status is for educational purposes only. Not legal or investment advice. Case summaries are provided for informational purposes and may not reflect the full complexity of the court’s reasoning. Consult qualified immigration counsel for advice on specific cases.